Purely Listed analysis
The Organic Athletic collection is independently corroborated as plastic-free down to cotton thread and natural-rubber/cotton elastic. The broader catalog contains many natural-fiber garments but cannot inherit that collection-level claim. No brand-wide plastic-free claim is assumed; sewing thread, elastic, linings, closures, finishes, and trims still require product-level confirmation. The score is brand-wide: an excellent 100% natural-fiber item does not make a mixed catalog synthetic-free.